A creative doormat with heart motif symbolizing home at a front porch entrance.

Never Say Never: The Plans We Make and the Realities We Keep

A friend recently shared something a doctor at a memory care clinic told her:
“Studies show living with a loving family is the most beneficial place for someone with dementia.”

I cringed.

I’m sure the doctor meant well. Maybe they were trying to reassure her that she was doing a good job caring for her mother at home. But statements like this, even when well‑intentioned, can land like a verdict. They can feel dismissive of the very real physical, emotional, and financial toll caregiving takes. And for many caregivers, they reinforce a message they’re already hearing from society, family, or even themselves: There is one right way to do this.

There isn’t.

And yet, how often have you heard someone say, “I would NEVER put my loved one in a nursing home!”
It’s a bold, black‑and‑white statement in a disease that is nothing but shades of gray.

These declarations often come from people who have never walked a mile in the shoes of a dementia caregiver. And even if they have, we all know the truth behind the saying:
If you’ve met one person with dementia, you’ve met one person with dementia.
No two journeys look the same. No two caregiving realities are identical.

So let’s talk about some hard truths in dementia care planning, not to scare anyone, but to ground this conversation in reality rather than guilt or absolutes.

The Hard Truths About Caregiving

Caregiving eventually becomes a 24/7 responsibility

In the later stages of dementia, a person will require:

  • constant supervision
  • assistance with all activities of daily living
  • support for mobility and transfers
  • help during nighttime wakefulness

No one, not even the most devoted spouse or adult child, can provide round‑the‑clock care alone. Love does not replace sleep, physical strength, or the need for rest.

Caregiving carries significant financial strain

According to CDC data:

  • 40% of employed caregivers reduced their work hours
  • nearly 20% of employed caregivers stop working entirely
  • 80% pay out‑of‑pocket for care‑related expenses
  • dementia caregivers spend, on average, nearly $9,000 per year out‑of‑pocket

Caregivers are at higher risk for depression

In one study comparing depression rates of caregivers compared to non caregivers:

  • Individuals who had been caregivers for at least 5 years, 32% met depression criteria, compared to just 6% of individuals in the non caregiving control group.

Chronic caregiving is emotionally heavy work. It changes people, not because they’re weak, but because the role is relentless.

Caregiving affects physical health, including mortality risk

Research has shown:

  • chronic stress increases IL‑6, a cytokine linked to heart disease, diabetes, arthritis, and certain cancers
  • these increased levels of IL-6 sometimes persisted for years after caregiving ended
  • caregivers experiencing strain have a 63% higher mortality risk than non‑caregivers

These physical risks are real, and they remind us that caregiving has limits. Understanding these realities is essential for realistic dementia care planning.

Questions Every Caregiver Should Honestly Ask Themselves

If you feel firmly committed to keeping your loved one at home, because you’re either opposed to long‑term care facilities or because you feel pressure to be the one who “should” do it, it’s worth pausing to ask yourself a few honest questions.

  • Do I have reliable, consistent support?
    Not a neighbor who stops by occasionally, but real, dependable help that allows you to sleep, eat, and maintain your own health.
  • Can I afford the financial impact?
    Lost wages, reduced hours, private caregivers, and medical supplies add up quickly.
  • Am I physically able to provide the level of care required?
    Lifting, transferring, bathing, and toileting require training and equipment to prevent injury.
  • Is my own health stable enough to sustain this long‑term?
    Your wellbeing is not optional. It is part of the care plan.

These questions aren’t meant to push anyone toward placement, but are part of honest dementia care planning. They’re meant to help caregivers make decisions rooted in reality, not guilt or pressure.

So What’s the “Right” Long‑Term Care Plan?

There is no universal right answer. There is only the answer that protects the physical and emotional health of both the person living with dementia and the caregiver. Home care is not morally superior. Facility care is not a failure. Both can be acts of profound love.

The right plan is the one that keeps everyone safe, supported, and able to experience moments of connection, not the one that satisfies a “never” statement made years earlier.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *